Friday, April 27, 2007

Uglies by Scott Westerfeld

Teenage girls really like this book. It is always checked out of our library, and it won the Abe Lincoln award last year. I can see why, even though I didn't like it much. The characters weren't well developed (the ending was supposed to be suspenseful, but I didn't care about the characters much at all after 400 + pages), and the whole thing needed editing. I found myself thinking...o.k., let's get on with it...and I would have liked more background information on the characters. What made Tally the way she was??? What about Shay, why was she so confident and able to reject the society's version of beauty/conformity??

My favorite part about it was the quotations on beauty that begin every section: "There is no excellent beauty that hath not some strangeness in its proportions"--Francis Bacon; and "Beauty is that Medusa's head Which men go armed to seek and sever. It is most deadly when most dead, And dead will stare and sting forever"-- Archibald MacLeish, "Beauty."

It is dystopic story about two teenage girls, Tally Youngblood and her friend Shay. When they turn 16, everyone in this society undergoes an operation to make them beautiful. The city is divided into two parts "Prettyville" and "Uglytown." Those who have not been pretty yet, obviously (too obviously) live in Uglytown. Shay decides to escape her fate and teaches Tally that there is another option...a place called The Smoke, where the "Rusties" used to live, and where you do not have to undergo the surgery. Shay is unable to convince Tally to join her, but Tally is discovered by Special Circumstances (the people in control) and they tell Shay that she will not undergo the pretty operation unless she leads them to Shay and The Smoke. Tally does go to The Smoke, and has second thoughts about turning the residents there in to Special Circumstances. She meets David, Shay's boyfriend, and his parents, who were originally surgeons who performed the operations... her concept of beauty slowly changes as she falls for David....

Before reading this book, I had considered using it as a bookclub selection for ESL students. Its themes seemed perfect because of all of the ethical questions involved: loyalty to friends, the nature of beauty, conformity. While the language was simple enough, the plot was unevenly paced and it was simply too long.

Despite my problems with the book, I'll continue to booktalk it to classes because of its popularity.

I'll be on the lookout for more interesting versions of this theme. Maybe Thinner than Thou by Kit Reed is the answer--for more sophisticated readers, anyway.

No comments: