Thursday, September 27, 2007

Brooklyn Books of Wonder

An interesting rant in The American Scholar. I wonder what he would say about The Road.

Links on The Road

Nick Hornby reflects on his reading of The Road on his "Stuff I've Been Reading" site. Someone criticizes him here. (I got these from the blog "Conversational Reading")

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

The Road by Cormac McCarthy

This is a great book that I didn't exactly enjoy reading. It is compelling and disturbing and makes you fear for the end of the world. The ending was great, in my opinion. I've read criticism about McCarthy losing steam at end, presumably by making the ending hopeful, but I disagree. The idealism of the boy throughout helps make the hopeful ending more realistic for me. Also, the fact that the woman at the end believed in God despite living through such destruction helps make the ending work. Maybe good behavior, youthful idealism, and respect for other human beings can survive in the fact of despair if one can sustain their faith a higher power. It makes me wonder what McCarthy's beliefs are.

It reminded me a lot of Night by Elie Wiesel. In that book, a father and son face similar despair and must decide whether or not to stick up for each other and share food with each other when there is so little of it. They too go on a journey-- I can't remember exactly what happens between them, but I do remember the ending when Elie Wiesel feels that God is dead. There is also an image of a baby being shot, that reminds me of the image of the baby in this story who becomes a victim of cannibalism. In both books, the characters have to fear all other human beings--even other victims. Though I don't remember the book Night as well. I do remember the feeling of dread I got while reading it. That feeling returned while reading The Road.

This is an Oprah bookclub book. On her website, it says that there will be an exclusive interview with Cormac McCarthy. I'll will be waiting to hear when that will be. I plan to read other McCarthy books soon.

Friday, April 27, 2007

Uglies by Scott Westerfeld

Teenage girls really like this book. It is always checked out of our library, and it won the Abe Lincoln award last year. I can see why, even though I didn't like it much. The characters weren't well developed (the ending was supposed to be suspenseful, but I didn't care about the characters much at all after 400 + pages), and the whole thing needed editing. I found myself thinking...o.k., let's get on with it...and I would have liked more background information on the characters. What made Tally the way she was??? What about Shay, why was she so confident and able to reject the society's version of beauty/conformity??

My favorite part about it was the quotations on beauty that begin every section: "There is no excellent beauty that hath not some strangeness in its proportions"--Francis Bacon; and "Beauty is that Medusa's head Which men go armed to seek and sever. It is most deadly when most dead, And dead will stare and sting forever"-- Archibald MacLeish, "Beauty."

It is dystopic story about two teenage girls, Tally Youngblood and her friend Shay. When they turn 16, everyone in this society undergoes an operation to make them beautiful. The city is divided into two parts "Prettyville" and "Uglytown." Those who have not been pretty yet, obviously (too obviously) live in Uglytown. Shay decides to escape her fate and teaches Tally that there is another option...a place called The Smoke, where the "Rusties" used to live, and where you do not have to undergo the surgery. Shay is unable to convince Tally to join her, but Tally is discovered by Special Circumstances (the people in control) and they tell Shay that she will not undergo the pretty operation unless she leads them to Shay and The Smoke. Tally does go to The Smoke, and has second thoughts about turning the residents there in to Special Circumstances. She meets David, Shay's boyfriend, and his parents, who were originally surgeons who performed the operations... her concept of beauty slowly changes as she falls for David....

Before reading this book, I had considered using it as a bookclub selection for ESL students. Its themes seemed perfect because of all of the ethical questions involved: loyalty to friends, the nature of beauty, conformity. While the language was simple enough, the plot was unevenly paced and it was simply too long.

Despite my problems with the book, I'll continue to booktalk it to classes because of its popularity.

I'll be on the lookout for more interesting versions of this theme. Maybe Thinner than Thou by Kit Reed is the answer--for more sophisticated readers, anyway.

Bruno in the History of Love by Nicole Krauss

Even after reading it twice, I still have questions about Bruno. Is he based on a real person from Leo's life, or not? I think it said in the book that he died on a "July day in 1941"--that's the same year that Zvi Litvinoff escaped to Chile. Maybe Bruno is based on Zvi. Maybe Leo thinks that Zvi actually died...

Also, I wonder if Krauss was basing Bruno on a real historical person. Young Alma finds a book under her bed called The Street of Crocodiles by Bruno Schulz. Maybe Krauss (or Leo) named Bruno after that Bruno. I read this about him on Barnes and Noble.com: "Bruno Schulz, a Polish Jew killed by the Nazis in 1942, is considered by many to have been the leading Polish writer between the two world wars." Here is a website on him--it talks about Schulz's view of artists and the purpose of literature: http://www.robertfulford.com/schulz.html

Thursday, April 26, 2007

History of Love by Nicole Krauss

I really like this book. Like Saturday, its themes stuck with me long after finishing. Also, I read it twice in attempt to get more out of it and I very rarely do that. The first time through, it took a lot of patience because the connections between the characters are so unclear; the second time it was a thrill to see it all and understand more.

It is the story of Leo, an elderly holocaust survivor, and Alma, an eleven year old girl who was named after a character in her mother’s favorite book, The History of Love, which happens to be written by Leo. There is also a third narrator—Alma’s younger brother, “Bird.” Leo, Alma and Bird have all lost a loved one and grieve alone. Leo lost his lover, Alma, when she escaped to the United States during the holocaust. He has lived in New York City alone ever since, and he has never met his son (Alma was pregnant with Leo’s baby when she left Poland). Alma, lost her father and now lives with her grieving, inattentive mother and her crazy brother. When Alma decides to seek the truth behind the character she was named after, she eventuallly comes in contact with Leo.

The end of the story was very moving. Alma and Leo shared so many qualities--the loss of a loved one, invisibility and loneliness. Their connection is intergenerational--between a child and a holocaust survivor. The holocaust survivor being recognized by a member of the younger generation could have been cliche, but it wasn't in my opinion. I loved the "taps" at the end and the unspoken relief.

Throughout the book there was also a lot about recording information about a loved one...or just being seen and recognized and maybe even preserved (in the form of writing or a sculpture.)

Here is a quote about Litvinoff, a former friend of Leo’s and the person who was credited for writing Leo’s book: "These things were lost to oblivion like so much about so many who are born and die without anyone ever taking the time to write it all down. That Litvinoff had a wife who was so devoted is, to be frank, the only reason anyone knows anything about him at all."

The sad part is that Leo, who really wrote the book about his love, the mother of his son, never had what Litvinoff did...

Wednesday, April 25, 2007

Saturday by Ian McEwan

I really liked this book. The narrator, Henry Perowne, is a neurosurgeon who has a scary run in with a crazy person named Baxter. Because Henry understands Baxter’s neurological condition, he is able to talk him out of getting any more violent toward him, at least for the moment. When Henry leaves the scary scene he is haunted by Baxter for a while....

It was such a good reflection of our times…the Iraq War and the post 9/11 anxieties. Scenes that stuck with me were: the opening of the window in the early morning when he saw the plane crash-landing at Heathrow followed by the anxiety about it later as he watched the news and caught glimpses of the pilots on TV; the tennis game—really well written; the argument Henry has with his daughter Daisy about the possibility of war, WMDs and overthrowing Saddam.

The last third of the book was the most compelling with the awful scene in their house. The slow pacing really picks up when Baxter reappears. And the ending…when we find out Henry saves Baxter’s life and decides not to press charges. I was surprised by that. After the surgery, when Henry is in Baxter’s room, and he thinks that he knows what must be done, I thought for sure that he had decided to kill him. McEwan made me believe that he had killed him later as well when we hear Henry’s thoughts while he is in bed with Rosalind. He decides not to tell her what has happened, or what he had decided. Again, I had concluded that he had killed Baxter after all.

I would recommend this book to adult friends, but at work, I’d talk to honors juniors and seniors about it. Some kids who are interested in medicine or psychology or neuroscience would like the unique perspective of Henry. The science blog, The Frontal Cortex, discusses this book. The descriptions of the surgeries and Henry's scientific mind are really convincing.

A possible flaw: At the car accident scene, I didn’t really believe that Baxter could be so easily talked out of violent behavior….but I talked myself out of it by thinking about the fact that Henry is a neuroscientist who, of all people, would be able to manipulate such a person. Also, this plot twist helped me appreciate one of McEwan's main points (as I see it anyway). Henry’s rationale for keeping Baxter alive, (the fact that Baxter was moved by Daisy’s poem, and that he understood it in a way Henry couldn’t) helps me appreciate the unique person that Henry is, and recognize his limitations. He, the scientist was able to manipulate Baxter once, but not when it mattered most. Daisy and her grandfather had to use poetry to do so the second time

Along those same lines, I also like the connection between the poetry and emotions and 9/11 and Henry’s struggle with all of them. I need to go back and read the Matthew Arnold poem "Dover Beach" to fully appreciate what McIwan has done.

The use of art in times of pain also reminds me of The History of Love by Nicole Krauss, but I'll save that for another posting.