Wednesday, April 25, 2007

Saturday by Ian McEwan

I really liked this book. The narrator, Henry Perowne, is a neurosurgeon who has a scary run in with a crazy person named Baxter. Because Henry understands Baxter’s neurological condition, he is able to talk him out of getting any more violent toward him, at least for the moment. When Henry leaves the scary scene he is haunted by Baxter for a while....

It was such a good reflection of our times…the Iraq War and the post 9/11 anxieties. Scenes that stuck with me were: the opening of the window in the early morning when he saw the plane crash-landing at Heathrow followed by the anxiety about it later as he watched the news and caught glimpses of the pilots on TV; the tennis game—really well written; the argument Henry has with his daughter Daisy about the possibility of war, WMDs and overthrowing Saddam.

The last third of the book was the most compelling with the awful scene in their house. The slow pacing really picks up when Baxter reappears. And the ending…when we find out Henry saves Baxter’s life and decides not to press charges. I was surprised by that. After the surgery, when Henry is in Baxter’s room, and he thinks that he knows what must be done, I thought for sure that he had decided to kill him. McEwan made me believe that he had killed him later as well when we hear Henry’s thoughts while he is in bed with Rosalind. He decides not to tell her what has happened, or what he had decided. Again, I had concluded that he had killed Baxter after all.

I would recommend this book to adult friends, but at work, I’d talk to honors juniors and seniors about it. Some kids who are interested in medicine or psychology or neuroscience would like the unique perspective of Henry. The science blog, The Frontal Cortex, discusses this book. The descriptions of the surgeries and Henry's scientific mind are really convincing.

A possible flaw: At the car accident scene, I didn’t really believe that Baxter could be so easily talked out of violent behavior….but I talked myself out of it by thinking about the fact that Henry is a neuroscientist who, of all people, would be able to manipulate such a person. Also, this plot twist helped me appreciate one of McEwan's main points (as I see it anyway). Henry’s rationale for keeping Baxter alive, (the fact that Baxter was moved by Daisy’s poem, and that he understood it in a way Henry couldn’t) helps me appreciate the unique person that Henry is, and recognize his limitations. He, the scientist was able to manipulate Baxter once, but not when it mattered most. Daisy and her grandfather had to use poetry to do so the second time

Along those same lines, I also like the connection between the poetry and emotions and 9/11 and Henry’s struggle with all of them. I need to go back and read the Matthew Arnold poem "Dover Beach" to fully appreciate what McIwan has done.

The use of art in times of pain also reminds me of The History of Love by Nicole Krauss, but I'll save that for another posting.

No comments: